A hand placing blueberries on a layered cake decorated with white frosting, berries, and small white flowers, on a white cake stand against a plain background.

The Pies the Limit Bakery is a specialty bakery located in the heart of downtown Rutland. We specialize in custom cakes, cookies, and cupcakes! 

For custom cakes, cookies, or cupcakes, please click here

Decorative cookies with floral and botanical designs, the name 'Adaleigh' and the number '1', on a lace tablecloth and wooden surface.

Custom cookies

Our custom cookies are not only gorgeous, but they are delicious as well!

“We had Mary do custom cookies for our wedding. Beautiful doesn’t even begin to describe them! They were almost too pretty to eat! Almost… :) I’ve had custom cookies from other local bakeries and they don’t even come close to being as delicious as Mary’s! I highly recommend and she has our buisness for forever!” Jessica S.

 We take your dreams desserts and make them a reality!

All cakes and cookies are custom orders and we book out quickly. We are all about quality, not quanity!

A two-tiered cake decorated with strawberries, blueberries, raspberries, green leaves, and chocolate drizzle.
Cookies decorated as black and white cow faces with floral accents, arranged on a wooden board with a paper doily underneath.
Decorated cookies with messages and symbols, some shaped like hearts, clouds, and flowers, placed on a wooden tray with a lace cloth underneath.
Three-tier wedding cake decorated with white pearls and small intricate white sugar beads, on a decorative cake stand, with a bouquet of white roses nearby.
A tall, round wedding cake decorated with pink and white frosting roses and a white piped border, placed on a wooden slice base with gauzy fabric and fairy lights surrounding it.